Skip to main content

Book Review: Hillbilly Elegy

This book, Hillbilly Elegy by J.D. Vance, describes my life so well it's eerie. I was born in Middletown, OH, into a Hillbilly Elegy. Some of the stories J.D. Vance told in this book could have been my own.

Like Vance, I worked my entire life to overcome and rise above my Hillbilly Elegy. I wanted something more than the despair and unreasonable use of alcohol I saw all around me growing up.

Fortunately for me, only half my family had the full Hillbilly Elegy in force. My mother and my maternal grandmother defied the odds of their Hillbilly Elegy by rising above it and insisting on more civilized behavior, which resulted in a more civilized lifestyle. Neither of them drank alcohol, even though both their husbands did. I don't recall my maternal grandfather ever drinking in their house and I would be hard pressed to remember ever seeing a beer in their refrigerator. It was an unspoken truth, known by everyone in the family, that my grandmother did not tolerate drinking in her house; we all knew our grandpa did his drinking out in the barn. I remember her not allowing my dad to bring beer to family dinners we had there.

My mother and her mother gave hope beyond our own Hillbilly Elegy and for that I am beyond grateful. They couldn't undo or overcome all of it, however, but the hope they planted grew, giving us something better to pass on to our kids and grandkids.

They are little things, really. Like going to the dentist. As kids, we never went to the dentist, but we regularly ate "sugar sandwiches." I remember brushing my teeth only at night growing up.  I did not see a dentist myself until my oldest child was seven years old and I had a really bad toothache. But, even then, I was already taking my kids to regular dental check-ups and cleanings. It might have been too late for some of my teeth, but my kids were going to keep theirs.

As a kid, the only doctor I ever saw was the eye doctor and that was because, when I was three years old, my mother realized I couldn't see. So, I started wearing glasses at age three and went to the eye doctor every year to get a stronger prescription.

We got some immunizations, but I got most of mine at school or a county office. People with a Hillbilly Elegy didn't go to the doctor unless there was something wrong. We did not do "well visits" outside of newborn status. When I became a Mom in 1982, I was shocked by how many times the doctor wanted to see my baby boy.

J.D. Vance captured all this in Hillbilly Elegy and more. The book became very personal to me, not only because it described much of my life to a T, but because my oldest sister gave it to me after reading it herself and wanted me to read it, too. I passed it on to one of my sons, who has promised to read it. I want my kids to understand where I came from.

Even though the book is filled with some of the worst cussing imaginable, it's still something I recommend because the cussing was an absolute part of the story; that's how some of my relatives talk to this day. My mother and her mother did not indulge in the cussing, however, and in refraining, they brought a higher level of thinking to our Hillbilly Elegy, leading toward another step up.

I no longer try to hide the fact that I have a Hillbilly Elegy. Say what you will about the Hillbillies I came from, but they are hard working, proud people who would never take a dime from the government. They might waste money on cigarettes and booze, but it was their money to waste, not Uncle Sam's. That's one part of my Hillbilly Elegy I'm proud of. Family helped family; I remember my maternal grandpa helping my mom with groceries to feed us kids when my dad had spent his paycheck gambling or drinking....or both. Family helped family even when they might try to kill them the next day. Nobody went to Uncle Sam.

I highly recommend this book. Vance exposes the opioid crisis Middletown, OH, faces today and his efforts to help residents climb above their hillbilly elegy. You can get a copy here.

~Tricia,
Y
our little Hillbilly friend


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Top Ten Most Common Edits - 2

My #2 most common edit is "toward." The vast majority of my clients use "towards" instead of "toward," as in, "Walking towards the entrance..." I correct this every time because in the US, where we use what is commonly called American English, the preferred choice is "toward," as in single. "Towards" is more commonly used in UK English and Australian English, as noted on Grammarly . In the USA, it's best to say, "Walking toward the entrance...." So, while "towards" is acceptable in other countries, for the US and Canada, "toward" is a much better choice. Keep moving toward good grammar! Write well. Write often. Just write. ~Tricia

Overcoming Failure - Part 1

Every writer has failures. Without exception. Dr. Seuss was rejected 27 times before he was finally able to get And to Think I Saw it on Mulberry Street published by Vanguard Press in 1937.  Search other famous authors and you will find they were all rejected at some point. Famed author Amanda Hocking came to my writing class with a thick folder full of rejection letters. When she, in class, learned about self-publishing and Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing , she published her own work. Soon, after selling over 1 million copies, she got the attention of some of the largest publishing houses. Then they fought for her. They could fight for you one day. In my book, Writing for Publication , I give 6 ways to overcome rejection and failure in your writing. My next 6 blog posts will each highlight one of these techniques. Appreciate your Own Talent If you know you are a good writer  and  if you have something valid to say,  appreciate that in yourself...